Prisoners Dilemma Introduced
There are many variants on the puzzle, however for those not familiar with the dilemma, here is one formulation of it:
Classic Formulation
There are two suspects in a criminal case, A and B. Neither A and B have any contact with each other at all. The police says to A that if A testifies against B, and B remains silent, A goes free whilst B gets a 10 year sentence. If A and B are both silent, both get 6 months in prison. If both A and B speak up, they both get 5 years in prison. B is told exactly the same thing.
So, each prisoner has a clear choice: speak up, or shut up. Speaking up carries with it a risk of getting off or 5 years in jail, shutting up carries a risk of 10 years or 6 months.
The question is: what to do?
Discussing the Dilemma
We assume that both A and B want the shortest possible sentence and they are both 'selfish' in that their sole goal is to get the shortest sentence possible, and helping someone else get off or condeming them to longer in jail does not affect their happiness.
This leads to a situation called a non-zero-sum games, where prisoners co-operate or betray the other.
What is very interesting, then, in this situation is that both will tend to co-operate, even though this doesn't give them the best possible result, i.e. getting off totally free, because they choose to minimise the damage. This is known as being pareto-suboptimal.
There are many real-life applications where the prisoners dilemma and other situations in game theory really do apply. One example is with an arms race between two states. They could both give up weapons or at least reduce them, or increase their powers. Because neither can be sure of what the other is doing (lack of trust) they both increase the weapons they have which is clearly not the optimal solution. The optimal solution is both reducing their number of weapons.
Your Thoughts
What are your thoughts on the prisoners dilemma? Have you come across real-life situations that reflect this in your work or daily life. We would love to hear about them and feature them on this site, so please do let us know.
Read more brain training articles:
- Mnemonics and memory
There are things that are easy to remember, things that are hard to remember, and things that you remember you don't remember, and... - Improving Spatial Awareness
The world around you is in three physical dimensions, so learning to understand and interpret that world is of critical importance. Here we look at ways of developing your awareness of the shape and space of the world around you and the objects and obstacles you encounter on a daily basis... - Speed Reading
Speed reading - the ability to extract key information from written text. How long will it take you to read? - stress and the brain
Are you feeling stressed? Well calm down, by reading this article on stress and the brain... - What Is Sentential Logic
The delights of sentential logic to the uninitiated may be a little bit obscure, but here they are in all their glory...
